Chivas USA3-2
FT
NewJ. Morales 30'
E. Torres 81'
E. Torres 45+2'
31' T. Cahill
86' D. McCarty
Chivas USANewChivas USA vs New York Red Bulls - 3 : 2 - Major League Soccer
May 23, 2012
New York Red Bulls
1 - 1
Jul 17, 2011
Chivas USA
0 - 0
May 15, 2011
New York Red Bulls
2 - 3
Jun 5, 2010
New York Red Bulls
1 - 0
Apr 10, 2010
Chivas USA
2 - 0
Sep 27, 2009
Chivas USA
1 - 1
Aug 15, 2009
New York Red Bulls
0 - 2
Jun 29, 2008
Chivas USA
1 - 1
Jun 5, 2008
New York Red Bulls
1 - 0
Sep 9, 2007
Chivas USA
3 - 0
Jul 26, 2007
New York Red Bulls
0 - 2
May 20, 2006
New York Red Bulls
5 - 4
Apr 29, 2006
Chivas USA
0 - 0
Oct 16, 2005
Chivas USA
0 - 2
Aug 21, 2005
New York Red Bulls
3 - 3