Columbus Crew4-1
FT
NewO. Kamara 6'
Artur 58'
J. Meram 69'
H. Afful 90+3'
78' D. Villa
Columbus CrewNewColumbus Crew vs New York City - 4 : 1 - Major League Soccer
Oct 22, 2017
New York City
2 - 2
Apr 29, 2017
Columbus Crew
2 - 3
Oct 23, 2016
New York City
4 - 1
Aug 13, 2016
Columbus Crew
3 - 3
Apr 16, 2016
Columbus Crew
3 - 2
Aug 29, 2015
New York City
1 - 2
Aug 19, 2015
Columbus Crew
2 - 2